Abandoned Mine Safety
Nonprofit works to close dangerous abandoned mines
GLOBE – “Fire in the hole.”
As Manuel Cruz uttered those words into his cellphone, explosives experts on the other end of the line set off dynamite in two abandoned mine shafts on park land just outside of town.
With two quick blasts, dirt and rocks filled the mines, one an upright entryway to the hillside and the other a gaping hole in the ground.
The city of Globe worked with Cruz, executive director of the nonprofit organization Abandoned Mine Safety, to fill in the shafts because they were just feet from a hiking trail and an easy walk from an elementary school.
Cruz, who ran unsuccessfully last year for state mine inspector, said he started the nonprofit because of the danger posed by thousands of abandoned mine shafts scattered throughout Arizona. The State Mine Inspector’s Office has only enough funding to close a small fraction of those mines each year, making it important for private groups and companies to step forward, he said.
“I believe every abandoned mine is dangerous in one way or another,” Cruz said.
Cruz’s group relies on private contributions. A donation from Tucson-based Rosemont Copper helped close the two mines here.
“Somebody has to do it, so private industry is going to have to step up,” said Dennis Fischer, project site coordinator for Rosemont Copper. “I think it’s an important thing to do, and we’ll continue to support this organization.”
Arizona law requires that abandoned mines be fenced off and marked, but State Mine Inspector Joe Hart said it’s crucial to do more.
“In my way of thinking, that’s not adequate,” Hart said. “I’ve got have an 8-year-old grandson who could reach any 4-foot barbed-wire fence. I want to fill them up.”
Hart’s office estimates there are about 100,000 abandoned mines in Arizona. About 10,000 have been pinpointed, and the vast majority of those are considered threats to public safety.
The reasons for closing abandoned mines may be simple, but the process for doing so is anything but.
It starts with money, which is in shorter supply due to the state’s budget woes.
Laurie Swartzbaugh, deputy director of the State Mine Inspector’s Office, said of a $1.2 million budget, about $180,000 goes toward salaries and other costs associated with closing abandoned mines each year. With some private donations added to that budget, Swartzbaugh said the office closed 146 mines in the last fiscal year.
“I think we’ve done a doggone good job, considering what we had to work with,” Hart said.
Hart said the paperwork necessary to protect contractors from liability when they close mines can take six to seven months.
Hart said he applauds Cruz’s efforts but worries that private groups may not take all the necessary precautions or be able to guard against lawsuits.
“There’s just a huge amount of liability, and it takes an awful lot of insurance to do it properly,” Hart said.
Rep. Russell Jones, R-Yuma, who has made abandoned mine shafts part of his legislative agenda, said he appreciates the help Cruz is providing. But he said that outside help might be more effective if organizations collaborate with the state.
“It does need to be coordinated through the state mine inspector,” Jones said.
In addition to working with private groups, Jones would like to see the state prioritize dangerous mines to eliminate the most dangerous first. He also said Arizona could use prison inmates to reduce labor costs.
Arizona’s abandoned mines are so old and scattered that it’s difficult to hold one agency responsible for fixing them or to expect a quick solution, Jones said.
“This didn’t happen overnight, so it’s not going to be fixed overnight,” Jones said.