McCain files bill to replace Obama's wildfire funding request
Navajo County Supervisor David Tenney told a Senate panel Tuesday that forest thinning is a “smart and responsible” way to curb wildfires and that fighting fires after they’ve started cannot be the only strategy.
The hearing before the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee came one week after President Barack Obama asked Congress to approve $615 million in emergency funding for wildfire efforts for the rest of this fiscal year.
“While I appreciate the administration’s proposal to spend more money on suppression, I would prefer a more fiscally sound way to address rising wildfire costs,” Tenney said.
Tenney was one of several witnesses, including senators, forestry and firefighting officials, who said prevention has to be part of the government’s plan for dealing with wildfires.
“I’ve watched my home state burn every summer,” said Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., one of the witnesses Tuesday.
“We lost 19 brave firefighters a year ago and over 20 percent of prime forest has been destroyed,” said McCain, adding that there is no higher priority than thinning forests to prevent the reach and intensity of wildfires.
McCain was testifying in support of a measure he is introducing, with Republican Sens. Jeff Flake of Arizona and John Barrasso of Wyoming, that calls for fully funding the U.S. Forest Service’s wildfire budget.
Their proposal would amend the Federal Land Assistance, Management and Enhancement, or FLAME Act, which set up a fund to cover the cost of fighting catastrophic fires. Besides easing the procedures to get firefighting funds, their bill would also direct the Forest Service to use a new wildfire budget forecast system and promote the use of private industry to help the service thin forests.
Obama’s request, included with an emergency border funding request, dealt mostly with firefighting, but also asked for authority to respond to wildfires like any other natural disaster, to speed funding and stop the current cycle of “fire borrowing,” or tapping other budgets to pay for fire response.
McCain said although he agrees that catastrophic fires should be budgeted like other natural disasters, his proposal would fully fund fire suppression to prevent the practice of fire borrowing.
Tenney said the “key ingredient” to managing forests is private industry, and that sawmills in Arizona predict a timber shortage later this year.
“We spend way too much time and money on putting out burning trees instead of cutting them and putting them to good use,” he said.
Tenney said he has seen “proof that forest treatment works,” saying thinned areas helped slow the recent San Juan Fire in Arizona. He said fire in thinned areas was “significantly reduced,”
“In untreated areas, (fire) spread was twice as fast, the flame lengths were 10 times as long and spotting was as much as a half mile,” Tenney said. “Certain portions of the fire spread were entirely stopped because of forest thinning.”
The San Juan Fire burned 7,000 acres and cost $6.5 million to contain – or $932 an acre, Tenney said. But it would have cost just $128 per acre to study, prepare and sell the land for treatment, he said.
“Acres of treated forest is better than 7,000 acres of nothing,” Tenney told the committee.