Sponsored by


Note: This story is more than 5 years old.

McSally raises millions, Dems trail in cash flow in close district

U.S. Rep. Martha McSally’s aggressive fundraising gives her an edge over her competitors in the CD2 House race, but experts said the district will likely still be competitive come November. Even so, national Democratic fundraisers have left Southern Arizona off their list of targeted districts.

The first-term Tucson Republican raised more than $3.2 million last year, topping all but a handful of House members, and had $1.9 million on hand at the end of the year, according to the latest Federal Election Commission filings.

The two local Democrats vying to challenge McSally are far behind: Victoria Steele raised $99,817 in 2015, while Matt Heinz pulled in $407,397 before Dec. 31.

That slow flow of cash is likely one of the factors behind the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee leaving CD2 off a list of 31 districts it's targeting this year. And political prognosticator Larry Sabato changed his rating of the district from "toss-up" to "leans Republican" last week.

But local Dems are working to tie McSally to national Republicans who might not play so well in Tucson, including presidential candidate Donald Trump.

While $3 million is a lot for challengers to overcome, analysts say other factors, such as the eventual GOP presidential nominee and outside funding, could have a large effect in the district, which is almost evenly split between Republican, Democratic and independent voters.

“An incumbent sitting there with a couple million dollars is a pretty tall hurdle,” said Nathan Gonzales, editor of the Rothenberg and Gonzales Political Report, adding that, “by the numbers, the district is competitive.”

Those numbers have been borne out in the last two elections. McSally lost to Democratic Rep. Ron Barber by 2,454 votes out of 292,279 cast in 2012, then came back to beat him two years later by a razor-thin margin of 161 votes out of 219,351.

Thanks for reading TucsonSentinel.com. Tell your friends to follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

“The Democrats would like to challenge McSally,” Gonzales said. “I think some Democrats still consider it to be (former Democratic Rep.) Gabby Giffords’ seat. There’s an emotional connection to the district. But the congresswoman has proven to be a phenomenal fundraiser.”

That has not deterred McSally’s Democratic challengers.

“We’re confident that we’ll have all the resources we need to run an effective, aggressive campaign against Martha McSally this November,” Keith Rosendahl, the campaign manager for former state Rep. Victoria Steele, D-Tucson, said in an email.

Steele raised $99,817 in 2015 and had $43,867 on hand on Dec. 31, according to the FEC. Rosendahl said recent polling commissioned by the campaign showed Steele to be McSally’s strongest Democratic challenger.

But the other Democrat in the race, Matt Heinz, has proven to be a better fundraiser so far, reporting raising $407,397 last year with $305,733 cash on hand at the end of the year. That is “right on our schedule,” said Bill Scheel, of the Heinz campaign.

“Obviously, McSally has raised a lot, she’s also spent a lot to raise that money,” Scheel said. “She has one of the highest burn rates of any candidate in the entire country.

“As this race takes shape, as Dr. Heinz’s campaign becomes higher profile, we’re going to end up being very competitive in the fundraising field,” Scheel said. “And we’re going to have all the fundraising we need to compete in November.”

McSally’s campaign said it is girding for that fight.

“We take no election for granted and will continue to work hard through Election Day, but it’s clear voters are happy with the job Martha’s doing, and all signs point to her re-election in November,” said Weston McKee, McSally’s campaign manager, in an email.

McSally spokesman Patrick Ptak said that the Democrats are "giving up on re-taking her seat" by leaving CD2 off the list of districts targeted for focused fundraising by the national party. "Given her impressive start and the Democrats' complete 180, it's clear they now consider her unbeatable," he crowed to reporters in an email.

Like what you're reading? Support high-quality local journalism and help underwrite independent news without the spin.

Gonzales said McSally has likely scared off others from entering the race, by building a “tremendous financial cushion” that would be strong in any district, including those in New York and California that typically draw large campaign donations. But he said she hasn’t clinched the seat yet, with other factors likely to weigh in.

The presidential race will impact congressional races across the country, Gonzales said, adding that McSally’s chances could be hurt if Republicans make “wild card” real estate mogul Donald Trump or conservative Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, their nominee.

Brian Murray, a political consultant who supports McSally, was less hesitant, describing her as a “fundraising animal.”

“I think she’s going to run away with it,” Murray said. “I don’t see any way that she’s vulnerable at all.”

But Democratic consultant Rodd McLeod said the historically tough district won’t be so easily won.

“Because of the way this district is drawn, it’s super competitive so she’s definitely beatable,” Rodd said.

In the closely divided district, Rodd said McSally’s voting record will leave her vulnerable, pointing to her vote to defund Planned Parenthood as an example.

The DCCC hasn't given up on blasting the Republican congresswoman, at least via email.

Trump's win in the New Hampshire primary "potentially crush(es) Martha McSally's dreams of reelection," said DCCC spokesman Tyler Law.

"Sadly for House Republicans, this Latino-hating, women-hating, Muslim-hating man is now their party’s standard bearer," Law said in an email. “This begs the question (sic): will McSally pledge to support Donald Trump if he is the nominee?"

While she has raised a lot, Rodd said McSally has also spent a lot on fundraising and not enough on talking with voters. He said outside spending from liberal and conservative groups will have a major impact on the race.

Gonzales agreed that outside funding, from the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee or other national groups, could affect the race, but he said McSally’s fundraising may have given them pause.

“It’s not an absolute lock that McSally’s going in,” Gonzales said. “There are other outside forces but she’s in a strong position and there isn’t a lot a lot of enthusiasm on the Democratic (fundraising) side.”

- 30 -
have your say   


There are no comments on this report. Sorry, comments are closed.

Sorry, we missed your input...

You must be logged in or register to comment

Read all of TucsonSentinel.com's
coronavirus reporting here »

Click image to enlarge

Madison Alder/Cronkite News

By the numbers

Funds raised by candidates in Arizona’s 2nd Congressional District in 2015, and cash on hand at the end of the year:

  • Martha McSally (R)*: $3,232,778; $1,959,252
  • Matthew Heinz (D): $407,397; $305,733
  • Victoria Steele (D): $99,817; $43,867